A Hawk has stepped up to claim the Reserves Best & Fairest on 23 occasions, with Mark Nicol claiming it on 4 consecutive occasions between 2003 and 2006. This equalled the record set by Ernest Gizzarelli, taking home 4 medals with Imperials between 1988 and 1991.
We thank Retravision Manjimup for their support of the LSWFL Reserves Competition and donation of the Best & Fairest Medal, along with the support of Greenacres Mill for the Runner Up trophy.
| Year | Winner | Club | Runner Up | Club |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 | ||||
| 1960 | G. White | Bridgetown | ||
| 1961 | John Ryan | Imperials | ||
| 1962 | John Ryan | Imperials | ||
| 1963 | John Ryan | Imperials | ||
| 1964 | M. Bendotti | Southerners | ||
| 1965 | G. Cassells | Southerners | ||
| 1966 | P. Radomiljac | Deanmill | ||
| 1967 | C. Church | Tigers | ||
| 1968 | P. Radomiljac | Deanmill | ||
| 1969 | A. Cabassi | Southerners | ||
| 1970 | G. Cassells | Southerners | ||
| 1971 | R. Doust | Bridgetown | ||
| 1972 | C. Barber | Deanmill | ||
| 1973 | C. Barber | Deanmill | ||
| 1974 | F. Vivian | Southerners | A. Piper | Boyup Brook |
| 1975 | J. Watters | Boyup Brook | J. Jonker | Tigers |
| 1976 | K. Burns | Boyup Brook | E. Reeves | Boyup Brook |
| 1977 | J. Guimelli | Deanmill | F. Vivian | Southerners |
| 1978 | P. Grigson | Deanmill | R. Green | Bridgetown |
| 1979 | Geof De Campo | Southerners | R. Peruch | Imperials |
| 1980 | Vince Pedulla | Imperials | M. Collins | Deanmill |
| 1981 | Fred Pedulla | Imperials | J. Cheffers | Boyup Brook |
| 1982 | Garry Kosovich | Boyup Brook | N. Selkirk | Tigers |
| 1983 | Sam Ditri | Southerners | O. Simmons | Tigers |
| 1984 | Alan Rees | Deanmill | N. Giblett | Bridgetown |
| 1985 | Michael Ostigh | Tigers | B. Muir | Deanmill |
| 1986 | Bruce Muir | Deanmill | M. Ostigh | Tigers |
| 1987 | Alan Rees | Deanmill | L. Palermo | Tigers |
| 1988 | Ernest Gizzarelli | Imperials | ||
| 1989 | Ernest Gizzarelli | Imperials | S. Kielar | Southerners |
| 1990 | Ernest Gizzarelli | Imperials | J. Krepp | Boyup Brook |
| 1991 | Ernest Gizzarelli | Imperials | M. Spiroff | Deanmill |
| 1992 | Neil Stallard | Imperials | M. Rumof | Tigers |
| 1993 | Sam Ditri | Southerners | J. Shaw | Deanmill |
| 1994 | Justin Shaw | Deanmill | B. Hurrell | Bridgetown |
| 1995 | Justin Shaw | Deanmill | P. Serafini | Imperials |
| 1996 | David Stone | Deanmill | A. Lukas | Tigers |
| 1997 | Justin Shaw | Deanmill | D. Needham | Southerners |
| 1998 | Gavin Ladhams | Southerners | G Hodgson | Tigers |
| 1999 | Robert Radomiljac | Deanmill | S. Carter | Deanmill |
| 2000 | Robert Radomiljac | Deanmill | A. Lukas | Tigers |
| 2001 | Ron Broderick | Bridgetown | D. Roberston | Tigers |
| 2002 | Ron Broderick | Bridgetown | J. Nixon | Southerners |
| 2003 | Mark Nicol | Deanmill | J. Nixon | Southerners |
| 2004 | Mark Nicol | Deanmill | R. Broderick | Bridgetown |
| 2005 | Mark Nicol | Deanmill | C. Lee-Steere | Boyup Brook |
| 2006 | Mark Nicol | Deanmill | H. East | Deanmill |
| 2007 | G. Matthews | Imperials | J. Martin | Boyup Brook |
| 2008 | G. Johnston | Tigers | ||
| T. Dellafranca | Southerners | |||
| 2009 | Clinton Best | Bridgetown | C. East | Deanmill |
| P. Omodei | Southerners | |||
| 2010 | Mack Herbert | Kojonup | J. Martin | Boyup Brook |
| L. Michael | Imperials | |||
| 2011 | Grant Johnston | Tigers | T. Della Franca | Southerners |
| 2012 | Ashley Sanders | Kojonup | Q. Kitson | Southerners |
| 2013 | Mathew Webb | Kojonup | J. Eyres | Kojonup |
| 2014 | Ashley Sanders | Kojonup | D. Rawson | Southerners |
| 2015 | Kayne Aitken | Deanmill | A. Sanders | Kojonup |
| 2016 | Nathan Ward | Tigers | M. Zadow | Kojonup |
| 2017 | Victor Markotis | Deanmill | J. Ipsen | Imperials |
| 2018 | Brayden Timms | Imperials | V. Martkotis | Deanmill |
| C. Best | Bridgetown | |||
| 2019 | Brayden Timms | Imperials | R. Nidd | Southerners |
| 2020 | – – | |||
| 2021 | Wesley Millar | Tigers | ||
| Jacob Maw | Boyup Brook | |||
| 2022 | Thomas Collins | Southerners | Jack Wilson | Boyup Brook |
| Michael Robinson | Southerners | |||
| 2023 | David Fall | Deanmill | Jared Edgar | Deanmill |
| James McAlinden | Bridgetown | |||
| 2024 | Jacob Henry | Deanmill | Martin Leggerini | Deanmill |
| 2025 | Jesse Potts | Imperials | Mitchell Clothier | Bridgetown |
